Chef Steen Turner pairs textures, colors, and flavor profiles — such as sweet, salty, and tangy — for Buchanan’s mouthwateringly fresh bruschetta starter.

Dining Out: Getting it Right

Buchanan’s Chop House & Whisky Bar in Whitefish is one of those rare Montana restaurants that knows exactly what it does best, does it expertly, and yet somehow defies the classic dining categories.

Sure, Buchanan’s is a chop house through and through, with hearty cuts from beef, pork, fowl, and game. And yet, the restaurant serves exquisitely imagined and executed dishes. And yet, the dining room has the vibe of a 1980s slopeside condo with framed ski posters, family sports memorabilia, boot-worn carpet, and whisky barrel and hurricane lamp décor. And yet, it’s the best meal I’ve had in a good while, which says something for someone who considers herself somewhat of a professional eater. And yet, it was also the most unpretentious meal I’ve had in that same span of time.

Turner relies on fresh microgreens from Intermountain Microgreens for many of his creations.

And yet. And yet. And so on …

I’ll say it like this: The food is at least 10 times better than it has to be. And you should put Buchanan’s, located near the ski slopes of Whitefish Mountain Resort,
on your short list. But be prepared for the delicious contradictions that keep this place feeling like a little bit of a secret. For now, anyway.

To get to the dining room at Buchanan’s, you’ll first walk through the lobby of the Kandahar Lodge, where people are gathered around the fireplace in overstuffed chairs, reading, playing cards or maybe backgammon. This is the real après-ski — the one before Instagram. To the left is the Snug Bar, an inviting hole-in-the-wall festooned with ski photos and old Wheaties boxes, where the bartender, TJ, will pour an old-fashioned to write home about. There are fewer than 10 seats in the Snug, but it just might be the best whisky bar in the state. To the right, just before the understated entrance to Buchanan’s, are the boot and ski rooms, where folks are unloading their gear before dinner. While some diners may have dressed up and come up the hill for a fancy meal, plenty others are still in snowpants and fleece tops.

TJ Fink mixes craft cocktails in the eight-seat Snug Bar. The Snug’s hours change depending upon the evening. “If there’s good people, we just keep the bar open,” says co-owner James Buchanan.

Buchanan’s is the second iteration of the family-owned-and-operated chop house, the first of which opened in downtown Calgary in 1988. After owners Carol and Michael Buchanan retired to Whitefish, their children James and Caitlin doubled down on the family’s success and last year opened a second Buchanan’s slopeside in Whitefish. Together, Caitlin and James still run both restaurants, traveling back and forth between Montana and Alberta as needed. Luckily, says James, the busy seasons for both restaurants don’t coincide. But even more key to their success, he says, is keeping true to the family-owned-and-operated philosophy.

“We’re light on our feet,” he says. “There’s no board of directors, no food-and-beverage guy. We print the menus in the back.” It’s clear from the moment we step in the dining room that James and Caitlin are having a blast.

James (left) often refers to Caitlin (right) in conversation as “my little sister.” The siblings grew up in the family restaurant business and have worked side-by-side in Calgary and Whitefish.

The first dish that comes out is a bruschetta. Simple enough, right? But this bruschetta is not like other bruschettas. It’s the end of summer on toast: house-made focaccia layered with just-picked heirloom rainbow cherry tomatoes, fresh basil, microgreens, and sultanas that add a balanced sweetness with white balsamic, olive oil, and honey. Next comes the Chop House Tataki: a tender wagyu eye of round, sliced thin and seared, served with ginger-lime ponzu, fresh microgreens, and fried shallots. The acidity of the ginger-lime pairs with the buttery meat in a way that conjures a meat lover’s version of ceviche. Fried shallots and garlic add crunch. James smiles at our obvious delight as we devour both dishes.

In addition to looking like they are having a really good time at work, James and Caitlin stand out from other restaurateurs thanks to a heaping portion of humility. “We think of it as mountaintop fine-ish dining,” James says. “Or, almost-fine dining.”

Fink is an artisanal alchemist, known for his fresh concoctions. The Golden Goat, shown here, mixes whisky, elderflower liqueur, lemon juice, Angostura bitters, orange bitters, orange marmalade, and honey. Considered by some to be Montana’s smallest bar, the Snug boasts one of the state’s best whisky selections.

As the plates keep coming, my partner and I determine that there is nothing about the experience, flavors, or service that is anything but fine. No -ish. No almost.

The quality starts to make more sense when you understand that before it was Buchanan’s, this 13-table, 44-seat restaurant was Café Kandahar, one of the most elegant eateries in the state under James Beard-recognized chef Andy Blanton. Café Kandahar was known for having a strong, classical foundation with French and Creole influences and an emphasis on local and seasonal ingredients. And the chef de cuisine working alongside Blanton since 2007 was Steen Turner, now the executive chef at Buchanan’s and the steady, driving creative force in the kitchen.

So how did James, Caitlin, and Turner pull off the almost impossible?

“By trying our best,” James says, knowing the stakes were high in following Café Kandahar with a different style but the same standards for excellence. “You’ve got to get it right the first time.”

James clears plates in the usually full dining room. He stops to chat with
diners and delights in Buchanan’s clientele. “Everyone is on vacation and is experiencing northwest Montana,” he says. “They all have smiles on their faces.”

The plush, cozy booth where we sit — which James admits he and his mother just finished upholstering together — gives a view into the kitchen, where the cooks move slowly, methodically up and down the line. There’s no music, no bustle. Only calm.

Out comes a perfect wedge salad with blue cheese, candied pecans, dried berries, and a garlic-basil dressing. There are only two salads on the menu. Which is fine, because next comes a long-bone Kurobuta pork rack that looks like a still life waiting to be painted by a European master.

Turner sources this cut from Snake River Farms, seasons it with fleur de sel and Chef Paul Prudhomme’s Meat Magic, char grills it, then finishes it in the oven, giving the pork a little char and a savory crust. The other elements include a sweet butternut squash purée, charred broccolini, and a
Flathead cherry and verjus demi-glace that balances the pork’s richness. He finishes the dish with crispy pork crackling crumble made from pine nuts, garlic, herbs, bone marrow powder, and local microgreens.

The long-bone Kurobuta pork rack is served on a cutting board, with butternut squash purée and charred broccolini like flourishes on a painter’s palette.

The knife in my hand is different than the one in my partner’s hand. Each is well-worn, functional, and looks like something your grandfather might have used to fillet a thousand fish. Still trying to make sense of the elegance alongside the casualness, I ask Turner to explain how high-brow cuisine pairs so easily with genuine service.

“To me, the two things belong together. I want guests to feel the love our team has for the food, the restaurant, and the mountain we work on,” he says. “We put a lot of time into making our food from scratch and creating dishes with Montana, French, and Asian influences. … The dining room reflects who we are. It feels personal because it is personal.”

Our dessert comes, and it is something: Honeysuckle pears — the Western Montana Growers Cooperative received only four cases this year, but Buchanan’s was able to secure one of them — poached in red wine and served with whipped honey, Meyer lemon chévre, crème fraîche, and a pistachio-almond tuile cookie. There is bittersweetness in watching a beautiful thing slowly disappear.

A writer and editor for various publications, Carter Walker covers art, architecture, food, travel, and culture. Her latest travel guide from Moon Books, Yellowstone to Glacier National Parks Road Trip, was released in 2026. She has a Master of Fine Arts in creative writing from the University of Southern Maine’s Stonecoast program and always has at least one creative project going. Walker is a founding board member of The Montana Project, which empowers Montana artists to advocate for the places that inspire them.

Aaron Agosto is a freelance photographer based in Montana’s Flathead Valley. His clients include Esquire Magazine, The New York Times, The Guardian, and The Wall Street Journal, among others. While not making pictures, he can be found out with his fly rod and his dog, Hayduke, on one of the state’s many rivers.

For the Chop House Tataki, Turner makes the most of tender wagyu by contrasting the heavily seared and seasoned exterior with a raw center.

Beef Tataki with Ginger-Lime Ponzu

By Chef Steen Turner of Buchanan’s Chop House & Whisky Bar

This take on Japanese tataki — meaning “pounded” or “hit into pieces” — uses thinly sliced wagyu eye of round and a delicious ginger-lime ponzu for one of Buchanan’s most popular appetizers. Select high-quality meat, and the acidity of the ginger-lime will let the flavors of the beef shine.

Serves 4

For Ginger-Lime Ponzu:

5 tablespoons gluten-free
soy sauce

5 tablespoons water

2½ tablespoons fresh
lemon juice

2½ tablespoons fresh
lime juice

3½ teaspoons balsamic vinegar

1 tablespoon plus ¾ teaspoon sugar

2½ garlic cloves, thinly sliced

1¾ teaspoons minced
fresh ginger

2 lemon slices, approximately ¼-inch thick

Turner was a dishwasher by age 10 and spent many years as the chef de cuisine for Andy Blanton at the renowned Café Kandahar. Turner loves the family dynamic at Buchanan’s and explains that the staff spends time together in and out of the restaurant. “That connection makes a difference,” he says. “We know each other, support each other, and care about what we’re doing together.”

For Beef and Garnishes:

1 pound whole, intact wagyu eye of round

Salt, to taste

Black pepper, to taste

Celery salt, to taste

Chili powder, to taste

Garlic powder, to taste

Onion powder, to taste

Paprika, to taste

Neutral oil, for searing

Crispy fried shallots

Crispy fried garlic

Fresh microgreens

Combine all the ponzu ingredients in a nonreactive container. Stir until the sugar dissolves, then cover and refrigerate overnight. Strain and measure out 1 cup for use in the dish.

Pat the beef dry and season evenly with the salt, pepper, celery salt, chili powder, garlic powder, onion powder, and paprika. Keep the salt balanced with the celery salt and the soy sauce in the ponzu.

Heat a heavy skillet over high heat with a little neutral oil. Give the beef a hard sear on every side, including the ends, creating a browned exterior while leaving the center raw. Immediately chill to stop the cooking. At the restaurant, I shock the beef in an ice bath, then freeze it and slice it thinly to order. At home, chill thoroughly and partially freeze until firm enough to slice very thinly.

Arrange the sliced beef on chilled plates, spoon the ponzu over top, and finish with crispy shallots, crispy garlic, and microgreens. Serve immediately.

Note: This recipe contains raw beef. Searing and freezing do not eliminate the risks associated with consuming raw or undercooked meat.

No Comments

Post A Comment

error: Content is protected !!